Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Jon Jost's avatar

Going to have to vehemently disagree.

"In a system that extracts from everyone the screenwriter pays the highest price. They are the origin point — the imagination that builds the world, populates it, gives it language and moral weight and dramatic structure. Without the writer there is no film. There is no director’s vision to realize. There is no performance to give. There is no award to collect......Without the writer there is no film."

You are writing about a narrow bandwidth of "film/cinema" - about narrative theatrical cinema as authorized and produced by an industry which is a propaganda system built around an ideological system - capitalism - for which the primary intentions are (a) to produce a profit and (b) express ideas which confirm its ideological foundations. This can be in Hollywood or Bollywood, or many other centers of film industry production.

There are other films/cinemas which do not begin with these premises, and which - amongst other things - do not require a script writer, nor most of the industrial apparatus, and do not require expressing the ideological beliefs of that system. Of course it is in effect a banned cinema, censored, usually with the instinctual knee-jerk a priori censorship of the assertion "but it won't make money/does not have an audience." It is not allowed to have an audience, a priori. And ergo, inside the system, should not exist.

I make such cinema. Even the few films of mine which received theatrical distribution, such as All the Vermeers in New York (ran 6 months in Chicago back when), had no script at all. Many of my films are not narrative at all but are loose essays, mixtures of narrative and quasi-documentary and essay. No, they don't make money, not because they couldn't, but because the entire system around them doesn't want them at all because they do not support the industry/propaganda/capitalist foundation of US social culture.

www.thefilmsofjonjost.wordpress.com

Elliot Grove's avatar

your articles are so deep and intense and wonderfully meaningful.

5 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?